By Christopher Bailey, Policy Lead, Jameel Arts and Health Lab, and former Arts and Health Lead, World Health Organization
I have always been a bit skeptical of an overly clinical approach to Arts and Health.
There was a time when a proliferation of small clinical studies would show drops in cortisol levels after artistic engagement as an indicator of lower stress, and over time, could potentially lower incidences of stress related NCDs among other benefits. The problem with an overly reductionist approach to Arts and Health, and an attempt to mechanize the process as a purely clinical intervention, is that it leaves the impression that stress reduction is the major benefit of artistic engagement, simply because we can measure it, leaving aside the rather obvious plethora of other less measurable benefits. Even the term Social Prescribing, originally coined in the UK with a bit of tongue in cheek, can give the impression of this operant approach. “Read these two sonnets and call me in the morning.”
What the science is actually telling us is that artistic engagement is all about sensemaking of the world, our relationships and our place in them. In many ways the Arts are much more about Public Health issues than clinical. The power of arts engagement makes itself more apparent when seen through a lens of community health promotion, rather than only individual symptom reduction.
My colleague Daisy Fancourt has for many years used cohort population studies to examine how arts participation may impact health on a population basis. An early example is one of her studies from 2019. Through these population studies, she has convincingly demonstrated a direct correlation between participation in the arts and a reduction in clinical depression, for instance.
Such findings are opening up the intriguing possibility that creative expression may be framed as a health behavior, not unlike good nutrition, regular exercise and sleep.
But in my experience, the arts are more than leading healthier lives as defined by accepted health measures. The arts assist us in our fundamental search for individual and collective meaning and a sense of belonging.
I sense this most acutely in communities that have experienced extreme adverse events. If we take the case of Ukraine, for example, one of the places I have been working since the full scale invasion a few years ago. There is an increasing interest from the grassroots level and throughout the cultural and health systems to better utilize the arts to recover from trauma and build resilience in the population. But to apply the arts simply as a clinical intervention misses the contextual reality of the war. The arts can never be separated from the conflict itself, as it is more than territory and people that are under threat, but the very concept of Ukrainian identity, including and especially its manifestation through cultural and artistic practice. The arts are not simply a health tool, they are one of the many dimensions in which the struggle is taking place.
Similarly, I have heard firsthand from communities who have faced genocidal practice, either in the past or in the present day, from the Yazidi community to First Nations peoples around the world, about their frustration with individualised clinical mental health approaches. To overly focus on the experience of the individual without appropriate inclusion of the community experience can leave the person feeling even more isolated and may indeed unintentionally serve the aggressor’s interest in breaking notions of common identity. For a more complete discussion on this topic you may wish to read this commentary.
Collective sense making and shared experience, through public performance or public art, addresses both individual healing and thriving while at the same time reinforcing a sense of community and belonging.
Having recently completed 23 years at the World Health Organization, I have been reflecting on what Public Health as a discipline has meant to me as a person. It is more than an evidence-based population approach to health. It is the common belief shared by Public Health practitioners that the chain of human health is only as strong as its weakest link. Public Health, like the arts, as a discipline helps people not only live healthier lives, but to feel common cause with each other and reinforce our common humanity. We are both individuals as well as a common family and that need not be a contradiction.
I leave you with a short clip from remarks I gave at the Healing Arts Ukraine event I participated in a few weeks ago in Lviv. It is my attempt to define the purpose of art.
Disclaimer: the opinions – including possible policy recommendations – expressed in the article are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views or opinions of EPHA. The mere appearance of the articles on the EPHA website does not mean an endorsement by EPHA.
