On 22 October 2008, EPHA attended a briefing to MEPs hosted by Phillip Bushill-Matthews MEP and Dorette Corbey MEP at the European Parliament in Strasbourg. The aim of the briefing was to give MEPs the opportunity to hear the consumer perspective on the Commission’s proposals on food information. Guest speakers from major European retailers, consumer groups and not-for-profit organisations outlined the measures required to ensure that consumers are provided with the information they need to be able to make healthier choices, and detailed their experience using colour-coded nutrition labelling schemes.
Willemien Bax from the European Consumers’ Organisation (BEUC) was the first speaker from the panel to take to the floor. She gave an overview of BEUC’s extensive work on food labelling issues, including research carried out in 2005, and their participation in stakeholder discussions. She also took the opportunity to outline BEUC’s position on the Commission’s proposals. BEUC wants to see mandatory front-of-pack labelling for Salt, Sugar, Fat and Saturated Fats, and back-of-pack labelling for the ‘Big 8.’ Front-of-pack labelling affords the consumer the chance to make an at-a-glance assessment of a food product’s nutritional value, and a simplified labelling schemes on the front of pack would act as an incentive for consumers to make healthier choices.
This was supported by presentations from the retailers Sainsbury’s and Intermarche, both showing that a simplified front-of-pack label allowed consumers to make a quick, informed choice. Sainsbury’s, one of the largest UK supermarkets, introduced a traffic light system on its ‘own brand’ products in 2005. It now has over 5,000 products carrying the traffic light system. Research carried out by the store indicates that over 60% of consumers understand why the traffic light system is there, and 32% actively look out for the symbols. They were motivated to introduce a system that was “best for food and health.” As a result of the traffic light systems, consumers are not only making healthier choices, but encouraging the producers to make healthier foods, as those products will sell better.
‘Which?’, a consumer association from the UK, and Bruce Silverglade from the Centre for Science in the Public Interest gave further evidence to support the need for a simplified labelling scheme. Figures from ‘Which?’ indicated that consumers from a low socio-economic background understand a simple traffic light system better than any other, and the same system also performed best amongst the UK’s main minority ethnic groups. Bruce Silverglade demonstrated how the complexity of nutritional labels can be an impediment to their effectiveness. According to research undertaken in the US, two thirds of consumers consult nutritional labels on the back of pack, yet only 29% understand the labels correctly.
All speakers present at the meeting agreed that there was a need to introduce a scheme that was complimentary to the GDA labels already found on packaging. The message from consumer groups and retailers alike was clear, if you don’t have a simplified front-of-pack labelling system, those who don’t consult nutritional tables on the back of the pack or can’t understand them are left without information. With a ever-worsening obesity epidemic, we need to encourage people to make healthy choices by any means possible. A front-of-pack traffic light system has consistently performed best in market research, and it was stressed that the European Union currently has an opportunity to put in place constructive legislation to encourage healthy choices.
For more information
[->art2959]
