By 26 June, the Irish Presidency of the Council of European Union intends to strike a deal on the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) reform for the years 2014-2020. After 20 months of tough negotiation, how likely is the CAP and crops its supposed to produce to contribute to public health objectives of improved health outcomes and reduced health inequalities?
In 2010, the European Commission announced its vision for “the CAP towards 2020” with the inclusion of public health and healthy nutrition warmly welcomed by the public health community.. In October 2011, the European Commission released a Communication on the legislative proposals related to the CAP for the years 2014-2020. Already in that legislative proposals, we could see a somewhat ‘relaxed’ stand to the policy. Whilst originally the policy was meant to “modernise European farming and food systems and enable them to better address today’s food-related challenges and contribute to the achievement of the Europe 2020 strategy for smart, green and inclusive growth”, its final text was significantly altered and a ‘public health’ dimension of the CAP was dropped.
Twenty months and a countless number of meetings and debates later, the goal of ‘good farming promoting good health’ can be hardly seen in the revamped CAP. Unlike the recommendations issued by the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) in its latest State of Food and Agriculture 2013 report, the soon-to-be agreed ‘new’ CAP is far from putting food and nutrition at the centre of farming and food systems. In fact, many wonder whether the new policy will bring much-needed and progressive change, or will it rather, simply reinforce the status quo?
There are many reasons to doubt that the CAP will actually change anything. One is the issue of ‘greening’, debated by many policy-makers and NGOs. The principles (or lack of them) of ‘convergence’, ‘equivalence’ and ‘flexibility between the CAP pillars’ are a real cause for concern – very much felt by the public health community too.
Not only is the public health community worried that the ‘new’ CAP is to remain ‘old’ – more agro-business friendly rather than health and nutrition-promoting. The policy as it seems is more about dividing money than looking into what it is to subsidise and to what result. Unfortunately, populations who struggle under diet-related non-communicable diseases (CVD, cancer, diabetes) and conditions like obesity and overweight, and who would benefit from greater production and consumption of fresh fruit and vegetables, wholegrains or legumes (known to promote health), products coming from short food supply chain, organic farming or simply increased access to those products, will find these objectives hardly at all taken into account in the policy and all the debates around it. The policy is not only likely to remain “business as usual”, but it is likely to be a step backwards with some of its suggestions.
The public health community finds appalling the European Parliament’s support of re-introducing tobacco growing despite the 2010 phase out of such subsidies and in spite of our advocacy efforts to remove this type of agricultural crops from coupled support. This issue was not debated during all 24 trialogue negotiations (between the European Commission, the European Parliament and the Council of the European Union) carried out so far. In fact, during the trialogue negotiations not one single issue on CAP reform was agreed (according to Paolo de Castro MEP, chair of the EP AgriCommittee).
So what’s next for the CAP this month? Will the Irish Presidency strike a good deal? Whilst the Council of the European Union has not been seeking a revised position, the European Parliament (EP) announced that the CAP deal will be impossible if all ‘sensitive issues’ are not resolved. The informal Ministerial meeting on the deal will begin between 23-24 June in Dublin with the objective of wrapping up the negotiations by 26 June in Luxembourg. But will it really? Will such a hastened decision advance a policy that needs careful consideration and proper assessment of the impacts it is likely to have on the environment, food supply, nutrition security, and public health? Although strong on their priorities, the EP (mostly pushed by its Agri Committee) is unlikely to soften its negotiating position (including the re-coupled support to tobacco). If necessary, members of the European Parliament (MEPs) should block, or at least officially not attend, the Luxembourg session. (their presence is crucial as the 2009 Lisbon Treaty gave them an equal co-decision power in this matter.)
What is EPHA doing?
Together with the European Public Health and Agriculture Consortium (EPHAC), the public health community has been sending letters to Member States’ Ministers for Agriculture to urge them to call for the removal of tobacco-farming subsidies. In addition, we have been involved in debates with other CAP-related Brussels-based NGOs on the issues of wider CAP reform implications.
—–
EPHA related articles
– [->art5708]
– [->art5660]
– [->art5657]
– [->art5646]
– [->art5653]
– [->art5628]
– [->art5625]
– [->art5616]
– [->art5616]
– [->art5614]
– [->art5613]
– [->art5581]
– [->art5560]
– [->art5557]
– [->art5515]
– [->art5466]
