Please read below EPHA’s amendments to the concerns of the High Level Group on the competitiveness of the agro-food industry.
As a representative organisation for civil society and an advocate for better public health policy in the European Union, EPHA would like to provide some general comments on the process that will lead to the final report: “Food 21”.
EPHA recognises that a stakeholder approach is important for the implementation of policy and for providing recommendations for future policy, but a clear line should remain in place with regards to “conflict of interest”. The agro-food industry is one of Europe’s main successes, and it should therefore never be forgotten that this was only realised by providing a clear framework detailing how the Industry should operate within the EU. The EU should improve the legislative framework in order to provide each industry actor with a clearly defined code of conduct. This can only be beneficial for the competitiveness of the agro-food industry, and will help to provide the consumer with the quality food products that Europe is known for. EPHA noted the absence of the health-in-all-policies approach in the report, and hopes the Commission will come to regard this as a potential benefit, and not as a cost. Europe’s Food products are trusted by its consumers, an obvious competitive advantage. This should be maintained by a clear regulatory framework which will benefit growth on a global scale.
Concerns:
I. Difficult access to raw materials:
– Tolerance threshold for GMOs- EFSA should be the only body to provide a scientific opinion on what the tolerance threshold should be, considering that EFSA is the risk assessor.
– Monitor impact of biofuels, pesticides, and GMOs- Complete impact assessment. Carried out by an independent body such as EFSA or Member States’ Agencies.
– Additional Point- EPHA would like to see an increased availability of fruit and vegetables. Fruit and vegetables are a competitive market for the EU. Subsidies should be focussed on this sector. In addition, at current levels of production, the EU is unable to meet the WHO recommendations for fruit and vegetable intake.
II. Common Agricultural Policy:
– Remove production restraints- A review of production quotas and subsidies is needed to see how the CAP can be brought more into line with Europe’s need
– Further research on new technologies- In particular on nanotechnology. In order to establish the potential benefits and risks for consumers.
– Additional Point- Introduction of a qualitative measure of food and produce quality (both aesthetic and nutritional)
– Amendment to Vision- A market-oriented CAP that allows farmers to respond efficiently to trends whilst maintaining diversity of production.
III. Trade and Access to 3rd Countries’ Markets:
– Promotion of European legislative requirements in international fora- EPHA fully supports this point.
IV. Relationship along the Food Chain:
– A European framework regulation is necessary for the contractual relationship between retailers/producer/manufacturers- EPHA supports the establishment of a European Framework for all incidences, not only in the case of malfunction as proposed by CIAA.
– Market monitoring mechanism (price, quantity, trade)- EPHA would like quality inserted.
VI. Workforce Availability and Skills:
– Food specific educational programmes- EPHA would like to replace educational programmes with a skills escalator, which will identify the staff and skills requirements of the agro-food industry.
– Additional point- EPHA would like to see the inclusion of a point providing for a European Framework on the Conditions of Seasonal and Migrant Workers
VII. Research and Innovation:
– Finance initiatives in food sector through FP7- EPHA insists this point be removed. It is not a core responsibility of DG research to finance innovative food.
– Additional points proposed by French delegation- EPHA would like to lend its support to the French amendments addressing the two challenges related to healthy diet. Public funding should be spent on these challenges. EPHA demands that within the framework of competitiveness, the EU and industry should take full responsibility for combating obesity by supporting research and initiatives addressing the issue.
– Additional point- EPHA believes there should be mention of an innovative approach to the issue of waste.
– Proposed Vision- Cross-sectoral collaboration, eco-friendly and new technology in production and manufacturing.
VIII. Food Legislation:
– Decision based on better regulation principle- EPHA demands that this be removed from list of actions/proposals. Competitiveness will not be achieved through less regulation. Food regulation and quality standards are precisely what give Europe a competitive advantage.
– Streamline existing EU labelling provisions- EPHA would support CIAA’s proposal to remove this action from this concern.
– Review implementation of EU legislation to prevent national legislation (top-ups and soft laws)- EPHA categorically rejects this proposal by CIAA. The EU legislation should act as a minimum, not a maximum. It should not force countries to lower their legal demands.
– Effective, functioning internal market- EPHA believes this should not be included under the vision for food legislation as harmonised food legislation could be a tool to encourage competitiveness.
– Strengthen confidence in EFSA- EPHA feels that confidence is redundant in this point. We would support a strengthening of the competencies of EFSA, including strengthening their resources. We also believe that EFSA should be given more risk management authority.
– Vision “Healthier, safer, more confident consumers…”- EPHA would like to see the Commission-proposed vision remain. We believe a certain responsibility should remain with industry to produce healthier products. Industry has a clear responsibility as food producers to bring healthier food to the market.
IX. Information to Consumers
– Clear labelling provisions- should remain in the list of actions.
– Better communication strategies for improving consumers’ understanding on innovative technology- EPHA feels this is assuming that hostility towards innovative technology, GMOs and nanotechnology for example, is based upon ignorance. This is not the case. We would like this removed.
– Additional point- EPHA would like an action point on information on redress included. Who is at fault, manufacturer or retailer. Consumers need to be informed.
– Vision- Build transparent and easily comprehensible information to consumers.
