The European Public Health Alliance welcomes the Proposal on ‘Nutrition & Health Claims Made on Foods’ as it will clarify and regulate health claims for consumers throughout Europe.
We believe that this proposal should aim to provide greater clarity for consumers to enable them to make balanced & informed decisions.
However, there are a number of areas in which EPHA has serious concerns in the draft proposal as it is.
For example, we regret that greater mention is not made of the public health dimension throughout the nutritional health claim proposal.
As stated by the European Heart Network, the ‘paramount principle in EU policy on health and nutrition claims should be the protection and promotion of public health’. We fully endorse that statement and believe that other factors eg economic considerations come only secondary to that principle.
In the introduction (point 6), it states that one of the main aims of the proposal is to provide a high level of consumer protection.
Although this is desirable, the proposal should also more explicitly aim to promote public health and nutrition, particularly as the claim is just that, a “health or nutritional claim”.
To that end we are writing to our members to ask for your input and expertise on this matter so we can better shape our response to this proposal.
Areas of Concern to EPHA
Article 4: Restrictions on the Use of Nutritional Health Claims
EPHA welcomes the addition of restricting health claims to foods with acceptable nutritional profiles, and the focus on fat, sugar and salt content in this respect.
However, as these nutritional profiles will only be set through the procedure described in Article XX, it in unclear how transparent and to what extent dedicated health professional input will figure into this process.
We recommend:
– Clarity about the precise consultation process including the names of Commission staff/committee who will set the nutritional profiles.
– Clear guidelines about the baseline standards of scientific evidence that will be needed to secure a nutrient profile.
– Input from the most appropriate health interest group as well as permanent public health representation in the consultation process.
Article 18: Community Register
EPHA welcomes the principle of disseminating information to consumers; the commission is proposing a register, which is to be made available to the public.
To better respond to citizen’s interest in this area, however, we feel that this register might be improved as an on-line searchable database where consumers could easily verify product information and corresponding health claims.
We would appreciate our members’ views on whether they feel that a register is the most accessible way for consumers to learn more about health claims?
Article 23: Committee Procedure
As stated EPHA is concerned at the lack of formalised public health input in the Standing Committee on the Food Chain & Animal Health who will assist the Commission in establishing nutrient profiles.
We would especially like members’ view on how they feel this process can be improved.
Article 24: Monitoring
We are concerned that the monitoring process consists of the manufacturers sending local authorities a copy of their label.
There does seem to be room for a more robust monitoring system, including an assessment on the public health impact of health claims.
EPHA would welcome your feedback on the above issues raised and any other issues concerning this proposal that may have been of particular concern to you.
– For more information on this issue, please read Eurocare’s response to the regulation on nutrition and health claims made on foods
Please use the forum at the bottom of this page to comment on this article.
