On November 2003 the Commission issued a proposal for a Regulation on the addition of vitamins and minerals and certain other substances to food . The proposal needs the approval of both the Council and Parliament under the co-decision procedure.
This Regulation aims to harmonise divergent national rules concerning the voluntary addition of vitamins and minerals and of certain other substances to foods in order to ensure a high level of consumer protection and the free circulation of goods within the Community.
The Commission proposal
Nutrients and other substances are often added to foods voluntarily in order to restore what is lost during processing, to produce foods that would be nutritionally equivalent to an important food item or to enrich foods with particular nutrients or other substances having a nutritional or physiological effect. The nutrients most commonly added to foods for the purposes mentioned above are vitamins and minerals.
The practice of adding vitamins and minerals has attracted attention in recent years because of the increasing scientific evidence of the relationship between diet and health.
The new regulation proposes the creation of a list of approved vitamins and minerals which could be added to food. Under the proposal, the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) would carry out the assessment of any possible risk to human health. The Standing Committee on the Food Chain and Animal Health (which comprises Commission and government experts), would establish criteria (based on EFSA’s scientific advice) for minimum and maximum levels for the different nutrients added to food.
The regulation would define clear labelling requirements to inform consumers about the vitamin and mineral content of food products in relation to the amount needed in a healthy diet.
Fresh food, including fruit, vegetables or meat, would be preserved in their natural state, with no addition of vitamins or minerals permitted. The same restriction would apply to alcoholic drinks – in line with efforts to combat alcohol abuse.
Finally, the proposed Regulation provides the basis for scrutinising and, where necessary, regulating the addition of certain substances, other than vitamins and minerals, to foods.
The Parliament
Karin Scheele (PES, AT), issued a report which modifyed significantly the Commission proposal. Over one hundred amendments were tabled to this report.
The Plenary of the Parliament adopted the report in May 2005.
The Council
The draft Regulation is also being considered by the Council which can either accept the results of the Plenary vote (law is then adopted) or the Member States adopt a common position which leads to a second reading in the European Parliament.
The EP can approve the Regulation in second reading just with a support from 1/2 of the voting MEPs.
The Council had a first look at the dossier in June 2005 and drew up its official common position in November. The most significant amendments to the Commission proposal include:
– the broadening of the sphere of application of the Regulation to include genetically modified food (Article 1(3)(c))
– the obligation on Member States to inform the Commission of existing national provisions on food fortification where such provisions are allowed by the Regulation (Article 11)
It is expected that the document will be presented to the Parliament in the new year so that it can begin teh second reading process.
EPHA members
This dossier has been a parallel process together with the Regulation on Health and Nutrition Claims made on Foods, dossier that has been closely followed by EPHA (joint actions with consumer organisations, media campaigns, conferences in the Parliament, meetings with MEPs, etc).
Several EPHA members are also following this issue focusing on specific issues. One of them is the British Fluoridation Society, which advocates for the use of fluoride for caries prevention. Although the Commission proposal included fluoride as one of the ingredients that may be added to foods, an amendment by John Bowis MEP, deleted fluoride from the list. The British Fluoridation Society is now planning lobbying activities at national level through their government representatives and through their MEPs to get fluoride back into the list, and would welcome any support from other national organisations.
