On 29 February 2012, the European Commission proposed several Innovation Partnerships in order to meet key challenges facing our society, in areas that are crucial to growth and jobs: one of these be sustainable agricultural productivity. The Commission claims a more concerted innovation effort across the public and private sector of agriculture and food production, in order to improve quality of life and position Europe as a global leader.
The Commission’s new European Innovation Partnership (EIP) on Agricultural Productivity and Sustainability is believed to achieve these goals. What is the focus the Commission takes towards food and healthy lifestyles in the proposal?
EPHA critical analysis
Although the Communication contains a rather positive direction towards the agricultural productivity and sustainability, it is done in a still pre-dominant light of increasing productivity by slightly or unchanged current production methods that are among the most polluting, resource-inefficient and depleting, energy-intensive and dependent on subsidies (often promoting agricultural production contributing to ill-health conditions such as chronic diet-related diseases). Instead, the EIP should stimulate local and regional food systems based on agro-ecological models, food producers, local authorities and communities themselves to find innovative solutions to local problems.
This – although little ambitious – shift towards more resource efficient farming is welcome, but it is essential that the recommendations made in the 3rd SCAR foresight report, regarding the concepts of productivity and sufficiency, are emphasised more in the implementation of this EIP. The EIP must considers the whole – integrated – food system, including public procurement, retailing, marketing and consumption. Moreover, it is essential to focus on truly sustainable food and farming systems with proven social and environmental benefits.
In our position on the reform of the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), EPHA stated that the EU agriculture policy can – and should – contribute to meeting increasing global demand for food. In order to achieve this, not only technology that increases food production will be required but an equal effort will have to be put into challenging current consumption patterns and providing incentives to move production and consumption towards increasingly plant-based diets. CAP must support investment in innovation in agriculture and food production, and support a balanced research agenda that not only invests in new technology, but agro-ecological and human ecological models of research.
Key points of the EIP on Agricultural Productivity and Sustainability
– European agriculture to respond to the major societal challenges of increased food demand through the productivity narrative while accounting for the constrained natural resources and environmental problems;
– huge potential seen in small and traditional farms, as well as diversified food supply chaines (long vs. short) in which “consumers are put at heart of these diversed food chains so as to steer production towards safe, high quality and sustaianbly produced food”;
– gap between relevant research and applied results to farming practices on the ground belived to be narrowed by investment in improved resource efficiency, increased use of renewable energy sources, reduction of waste; these is to be achieved by increased cross-sectoral and multi-level cooperation; in particular synergies are sought in the CAP, Union Research and Innovation Policy, Cohesion Policy, Environmental and Climate Change Policy, Consumer and Health Policy, as well as Education; (Social, Employment and Equal Opportunities policy should be added though, given their current work on Social Innovation and Social Change, equity and gender mainstreaming, poverty and social exclusion, among others);
– the EIP is to strenghten the role of farmers in the supply chain, re-balance the power towards the local and regional food systems, mainly by speeding up and promoting changes in consumer demand towards safe, healthy and high quality food to be found in local markets; this in turn is expected to provide economic development, employment and possibility for social innovation;
– themes (already pre-defined in general terms) are to be defined by Joint Programming Initiatives, the Standing Committee on Agricultural Research (SCAR), ERA-Nets, and European Technology Platforms;
– the EIP to serve as a platform for cooperation between farmers, researchers and stakeholders, including NGOs (however, it is up to MS to put such composition in place);
Areas for innovative actions (in line with a bottom-up approach combined with effective networking):
– increased agricultural productivity, output and resource efficiency (described above);
– innovation in support of the bio-based economy (in line with the EC Communication on Bio-based Economy): focus on higher quality of final products, especially better nutritional profiles, bio-fuels, bio-mass, GMOs and cloning;
– biodiversity, ecosystem services and soil functionality: focus could be put on integrated agro-ecological systems, low input organic systems, natural ecosystem conservation methods;
– innovative products and services for the integrated supply chain: better information systems and risk management tools, f.e. sustainability standards, farmers’ role in food supply chains, shortening of food supply chains, tracking environmental and social performance of farms;
– food quality, food safety and healthy lifestyles: the EIP emphasises the role informed consumer choices play as incenticising the whole supply chain towards safe, secure and healthy food production; the main focus is placed on food quality schemes and livestock health care, medical flora, biological qualities of food; from a public health perspective the most important will be tools for changing consumption patterns and education, information, and learning tools “in order to help improve public health, accompanied by healthy ingredients in products achieved by further developing nutrients and through animal breeding”; also, the consumers’ role in reducing food waste could be addressed by “intelligent packaging” approaches as well as education and information;
To conclude with, nothing has been said about healthy and nutritious diets, such as increased fruit and vegetables, affordability, accessibility and availability of healthy and sustainable diets, equity or social objectives of agriculture and rural development – known to be important if any research and innovation to truly reflect societal concerns.
—–
EPHA related articles:
– [->art4089]
– [->art4792]
– [->art4880]
– [->art4879]
– [->art4948]
– [->art4827]
