Publications

by | February 28, 2013 | Reports

EU’s Common Agricultural Policy – between Continuity and Reform

EPHA received an invitation to the policy debate facilitated by the Hans Seidel Stiftung held on 25 February 2013 18:30-21:00 at the representation of the Free State of Bavaria. The following article contains the arguments/key messages addressed by the speakers.

Introduction

Europe is entering a decisive period. Tight budgets, the pressure of globalisation and growing mistrust towards Brussels requires an efficient use of resources and a concentration on priorities. Together with Cohesion Policy, the common agricultural policy (CAP) constitutes the core of collective action in Europe.

The guiding principles for the long-term development of the CAP are indisputable:

  • Europe‘s agriculture has to become more sustainable, regarding the use of land, fairer, regarding direct payments and simpler, regarding administrative burdens.

The course for this re-orientation is being shaped now. The European Commission’s legislative proposals were presented in 2010; the Multiannual Financial Framework is close to an agreement; the European Parliament will vote on the CAP reform in mid-March; and the Council intends to give its position at the end of March.

Some of the main items of the CAP under discussion

  • The mandatory rules for maintaining ecological focus areas.
  • The adjustment of direct payments between and within member states.
  • The capping of direct payments for big holdings

Ms Ilse AIGNER Federal Minister for Food, Agriculture and Consumer Protection of Germany (DE) was critical about possible differences in the amount of direct payments resulting from proposed changes to the payment system. She said it may lead to a situation where neighbouring farmers would receive different amounts of money.There is also the need for a safety net if farmers cannot sell their products on the open market.

– Short overview about the 25-26 AGRI Council meeting.

Georg HÄUSLER, Head of Cabinet of the Commissioner for Agriculture and Rural Development

  • referred to the data quoted by the Environmental Commissioner according to which 15% of EU land is considered environmentally degraded and in need of improvement
  • voluntary greening measures, already in place, have not achieved the desired effects. That is why mandatory greening measures seem to be essential.
  • The increased flexibility between the 1st and 2nd pillar can undermine the aims of the CAP reform

Albert DESS, MEP (EPP, DE) Comagri coordinator, EPP-group

  • The European Parliament will vote on 13 March and the plenary usually follows the lines outlined by the AGRI Committee
  • 6 March is the deadline for sending amendments
  • The Commission proposal is too complicated – why shouldn’t we use a simple (e.g. 20%) target for the whole agricultural sector to make change happen?
  • The European Parliament made it clear, by giving a negotiating mandate to the free-trade negotiations, that it would not accept a lowering of European environmental, quality and hygiene standards

Lutz RIBBE Director, Euronature

  • The European Parliament has greater powers so it would have been ridiculous if the EP had delegated this power to committee level.
  • He was disappointed with the AGRI outcome since ‘EP had put on the brakes’
  • The debate should be led around the very basic question: what kind of legitimacy should the CAP policy still have? If we use taxpayers’ money we should have at least a good reason to do so.
  • If the environmental benefits were achieved there would be no need for greening
  • The AGRI Committee included hundreds of exceptions in respect of greening which is unacceptable. With this direction there will be more ecological focus areas around highways than on cultivated land
  • The CAP provides financial assistance if farmers follow existing legislation. Agreeing to greening measures means that it will not be enough just to obey the law.
  • The CAP is not about punishing farmers but providing them with taxpayers’ money. Greening is not about bringing economic advantages to farmers, but to positive environmental outcomes

Pekka PESONEN Secretary General, Copa-Cogeca (European Farmers and Agricooperatives)

  • Due to the framework set by the European Council, the 15% decrease in overall support to farmers is a fact, yet administrative costs will increase. Farmers will have to make up the difference by increasing prices.
  • COPA-COGECA is not against greening in an economic viable manner. The projected greening measures will result in even more costs for the agricultural sector. The set aims will be achieved so that we do not need to take any land out of production.
  • The CAP reform should take into consideration the WTO obligations, as well
  • The farmers who already fulfilled environmental obligations (e.g. organic farmers) will face the same requirements as the others who did not.
  • The legitimacy of the CAP relies on the fact that there are several million farmers who are not hobby farmers but who actively contribute to Europe’s productivity and in addition to that they take care of the land.COPA-COGECA accepts that the CAP could be a tool that European agriculture can organise itself
  • COPA-COGECA always accepted the principle of greening but it desires a greening which make economic sense and which does not prevent a farmer from making an adequate living for his/her family
  • Instead of punishing farmers, they should be rewarded to have better outcomes so that they can contribute to Europe’s economic green growth.
  • COPA-COGECA considers the second pillar as an innovative tool which can contribute to the first pillar.
  • He stressed that the co-financing element is missing from the current line which means that member states cannot contribute to farmers from national budgets
  • In Denmark, the majority of farmers are organic.
  • Current trends suggest that agricultural prices will rise, which will produce a huge political push to reduce the 1st pillar.
  • He warned that potential EU-US free trade agreements could lead to acceptance of US safety-standards

Dr. Andreas Biesantz from Demeter (organisation of organic farmers) said that organic farmers use ecological friendly measures because of their internal conviction so there should be a place for idealism in the CAP which might have beneficial effects.

——
-The agenda is available here in English and in German

——————

Get the EPHA Newsletter

The best of our activities, right in your inbox!