On 4 December 2012 EPHA attended the 3rd annual Data Protection and Privacy Conference in Brussels. The event examined the Commission’s proposals for a revision of the data protection framework in the EU.
The Data Protection and Privacy Conference brought together policy-makers, industry and regulators to discuss the principles and implications of the General Data Protection Regulation currently under discussion in the European Parliament and the Council.
Vice-President and Commissioner for Justice, Fundamental Rights and Citizenship, Viviane Reding, presented the Commission’s view and spoke about the debates that have been sparked since the release of the proposal. She highlighted a number of areas where the Commission is willing to, and is actively engaged in, finding compromise arrangements – for example, Ms Reding stated that the provision requiring notification of supervisory authorities in the event of any breach has been scrapped, and that the Commission is happy to remove or edit language which is deemed ‘overly prescriptive’. In response to the suggestion that different rules should be applied to private and public organisations, Ms Reding noted that the sector responsible for most data protection breaches is the healthcare sector – therefore, any such division seeking weaker rules for public as opposed to private organisations would be dangerous. Finally, regarding concerns about the number of delegated acts, Ms Reding confirmed that the Commission has reviewed those acts contained in the proposal one-by-one, deleting a number of them, and is willing to explore other ways of providing flexibility and legal clarity.
In a session focused on how the new Regulation will work in practice, the panel highlighted some of the specific issues concerning consent, data portability, the right to be forgotten, and the costs of implementing new rules on data protection. In particular, it was noted that identity theft is increasingly changing from financial identity theft to medical identity theft – this is most acutely evident in the United States, where inequalities in insurance status as regards healthcare are so defined, but is not confined to this healthcare market. Health and medical data is recognised as an area of extreme sensitivity and increasing digitalisation.
The afternoon breakout session focused upon reconciling data protection with the protection of other fundamental rights and finding the correct balance between these values. The discussion focused primarily on the intersection between the fundamental right to privacy and the use of data for law enforcement, and that between the creative industries and online provision of creative content. Some constructive comments were made about the need for an overarching structure of fundamental right protection – whilst each sector has different concerns and priorities with regards to data protection, an institution such as the Council of Europe might have a valuable role to play in providing an umbrella of guidance in the protection of rights.
The incoming Irish Presidency has made the data protection package a priority for its stewardship next year.
—-
Related articles:
-[->5211]
-[->5438]
-[->5422]
-[->5477]
