24 June 2014 –
The European Public Health Alliance (EPHA) – Europe’s leading NGO advocating for better health for all – is writing to you in light of the current debate in the European Commission regarding the impact of the United Kingdom’s voluntary colour-coded nutrition labelling. Together with the Royal College of Physicians, European Institute of Women’s Health and the International Diabetes Federation Europe – we would like to express our strong support for the UK government’s decision taken as a part of their Public Health Responsibility Deal (1) and we hope it will lead to other countries across Europe following suit
Dear Commissioners Tajani, Tonio Borg and Neven Mimica,
We believe that the UK simplified front-of-pack nutrition labelling scheme provides an extremely efficient and easily understood element to help consumers make the healthiest choice in nowadays increasingly complicated food environments. The UK scheme is tightly aligned with current European trend (also favoured by the European Commission itself) to explore and adopt new ‘alternative regulatory mechanisms’ which include self- and co-regulation. In parallel with encouraging the European Commission to regulate in matters affecting public health, including consumer-friendly nutrition labelling, we call on you not to put in question this national-level initiatives that is proven to sustainably benefit the interest of UK consumers.
The use of colour-coding aims to interpret the levels of key nutrients in pre-processed food products namely (saturated) fat, sugar and salt. The purpose of providing nutrition information is to allow consumers to make informed choices. Independent international research has provided convincing evidence to suggest that consumers find the multiple colour coding ’traffic light system’ the easiest to understand (2). The system makes it clear to consumers whether a product contains low, medium or high levels of a certain nutrient, and helps them to make choices both within and across food categories. The system would be particularly useful for interpreting the health risk of convenience foods, as this is where consumers have the most difficulty identifying healthier options. Consumers would benefit most from front-of-pack, at-a-glance information in a form of red, amber and green signs on convenience foods.
—–
We are aware that this voluntary UK scheme has been met with criticism by some EU Member States, and challenged in front of the Council of the European Union (October and November 2013 sessions) on the grounds that it potentially discriminates against certain foods or categories of foods, and that it would ‘fragment the issue of nutrition labelling in the EU’. We feel quite the contrary – the ‘traffic light system’ spotlights individual nutrients to give information to consumers to help them make an informed and honest assessment on how a given product contributes to their overall diet.
—–
We urge you to disregard this criticism. The scheme is in compliance with all EU legislation, and the UK government has been monitoring the scheme’s implementation which presents no barriers to trade. Article 35 of the EU Regulation on the Provision of Food Information to Consumers (1169/2011) clearly states that “individual Member States and the industry are allowed to trial different schemes as there was no agreement on what worked best across the European Union.” (3). Of course, the scheme is to be reviewed in 2017, by which time we are positive that the results will prove the scheme’s usefulness.
The public health community is extremely positive that the UK scheme will bring benefits to consumers and healthcare systems in both the short and long term. Furthermore, we hope that other EU Member States – where consumers still find it difficult to make easier, more informed and healthier choices, will follow this example.
We hope that by facilitating healthier choices for consumers, the burden of obesity, diet-related non-communicable diseases and health inequalities can be reduced across the European Union.
Yours sincerely,
Peggy Maguire, President, European Public Health Alliance and Secretary General, European Institute of Women’s Health
João Manuel Valente Nabais, President, International Diabetes Federation Europe
Paul Belcher, Principal EU Advisor Royal College of Physicians
(1) UK Government Department of Health “Final design of consistent nutritional labelling system given green light.”
(2) Draper et al. (2011). Front-of-pack nutrition labelling: are multiple formats a problem for consumers? European Journal of Public Health.
(3)Regulation on the Provision of Food Information to Consumers
