The US Department of Agriculture is proposing dietary advice that for the first time recognizes that a majority of Americans, 64 percent, are overweight and sedentary and need to eat less. Until now, the department’s Food Guide Pyramid has been aimed at the nation’s healthy population. Under the current proposals, recommendations for these more active people would continue to be available but would no longer be the central focus of government nutrition information.
The new recommendations call for most women from 35 to 70 years old, for instance, to eat 1,600 to 1,800 calories a day, and for most men in that age group to eat 2,000 to 2,200 calories. This is 600 calories less than previous guidelines.
The proposals will be subject to a period of public comment and will serve as a basis for a new Food Guide Pyramid.
The pyramid, which depicts food groups and the number of servings of each to be consumed daily, makes grains the diet’s largest component, at the bottom of the pyramid, and recommends that fats, oils and sugars be eaten sparingly. That will continue to be the case in the new pyramid.
The proposals are also intended to meet the Institute of Medicine’s new nutritional standards for vitamins, minerals and macronutrients like protein, fat and cholesterol. They include recommendations for a greater intake of fiber and vitamin E, and also say that half the grains consumed should be whole grains, advice that was not previously specified.
Another first under the proposals is that the government would provide guidance on what constitutes an active or a somewhat active lifestyle. That could help people determine whether they should follow the caloric advice for the sedentary category or would be able to add calories because they exercised – as much as 600 more calories for very active women, and 800 for men.
But several experts have criticised the proposals saying that the minor changes in the review do notaddress the fundamental problems of the pyramid, for example not making distinctions between high-fat cheese and fat-free milk, or between nuts and fish versus fatty meats.
