On 30 January 2008, the European Commission published its proposal for a Regulation on the Provision of Food Information to Consumers. Since then, the issue has been strongly debated and went through a second reading process. The European Parliament finally voted on the dossier on the 6th July 2011. The new Regulation 1169/2011 was adopted on 27 November 2011, entering into force on 13 December 2014.
*Update 27 November 2011*
On the 27th of November 2011, the new EU Regulation 1169/2011 on the provision of food information to consumers considerably changes existing legislation on food labelling including:
– Nutrition information on processed foods;
– Origin labelling of fresh meat from pigs, sheep, goats and poultry;
– Highlighting allergens e.g. peanuts or milk in the list of ingredients;
– Better legibility i.e. minimum size of text;
– Requirements on information on allergens also cover non pre-packed foods including those sold in restaurants and cafés.
The new rules will apply from 13 December 2014. The obligation to provide nutrition information will apply from 13 December 2016.
With regards to alcohol, it is proposed to: “Taking into account the specific nature of alcoholic beverages, it is appropriate to invite the Commission to analyse further the information requirements for those products. Therefore, the Commission should, taking into account the need to ensure coherence with other relevant Union policies, produce a report within 3 years of the entry into force of this Regulation concerning the application of the requirements to provide information on ingredients and nutrition information to alcoholic beverages. In addition, taking into account the resolution of the European Parliament of 5 September 2007 on an European Union strategy to support Member States in reducing alcohol-related harm, the opinion of the European Economic and Social Committee, the work of the Commission, and general public concern about alcohol-related harm especially to young and vulnerable consumers, the Commission, after consultation with stakeholders and the Member States, should consider the need for a definition of beverages such as ‘alcopops’, which are specifically targeted at young people“.
Front and/or back of packaging information: “it is necessary to clarify which information may be repeated“.
“In order to encourage food business operators to provide on a voluntary basis the information contained in the nutrition declaration for foods such as alcoholic beverages and non-prepacked foods that may be exempted from the nutrition declaration, the possibility should be given to declare only limited elements of the nutrition declaration. It is nevertheless appropriate to clearly establish the information that may be provided on a voluntary basis in order to avoid misleading the consumer by the free choice of the food business operator. ” “There have been recent developments in the expression of the nutrition declaration, other than per 100 g, per 100 ml or per portion, or in its presentation, through the use of graphical forms or symbols, by some Member States and organisations in the food sector. Such additional forms of expression and presentation may help consumers to better understand the nutrition declaration. However, there is insufficient evidence across all the Union on how the average consumer understands and uses the alternative forms of expression or presentation of the information. Therefore, it is appropriate to allow for different forms of expression and presentation to be developed on the basis of criteria established in this Regulation and to invite the Commission to prepare a report regarding the use of those forms of expression and presentation, their effect on the internal market and the advisability of further harmonisation “. On the 6th of July 2011, the European Parliament adopted, in plenary, the Food Information to Consumers proposal for a Regulation that has been debated over the past few years. The key elements of the new regulation are the following: – a nutritional declaration for energy, sugar, salt, carbohydrates, protein, fat and saturated fat, mandatory, to appear on the Back of the Pack, and to be expressed per 100gr/100ml and in addition per portion. The levels of fat, saturated fat, sugar and salt can, on a voluntary basis, be placed on the front of the pack, As it was agreed in the compromise reached between the Hungarian Presidency, the European Commission and the Parliament, the text will come into force three years after its official publication in the Official Journal of the EU, with the exception of the nutritional declaration part that will enter into force five years after. ——– On 22 June 2011, the Permanent Representatives Committee of the EU approved the agreement reached by the Hungarian Presidency, the European Commission and the European Parliament on the Food Information to Consumers Proposal for a Regulation. The key elements of the agreement are as follows: – on the issue of the mandatory nutrition declaration, – on the issue of forms of expression, the agreement reached allows the use of other forms of expression when labelling nutrients (with the condition that they are understandable by the consumer and that they do not represent an obstacle to the free movement of goods). – on the issue of transfats, the Commission should come up with a report on the impacts of measures such as transfats labelling, restrictions or ban in three years after the entry into force of the Regulation, – on the issue of alcohol labelling, all alcoholic beverages containing more than 1.2% volume of alcohol are exempted from the legislation, including alcopops. The European Commission should come up with a report, within three years after the implementation of the Regulation, on the possibility to label alcoholic beverages in the future. More generally, the parties agreed on the new proposal to apply three years after its publication in the Official Journal of the EU exception of the mandatory nutrition declaration that must apply in the five years after the implementation. Next step: European Parliament plenary vote in July On 16 March 2011, the ENVI Committee met in order to exchange on the second reading of the Food Information to Consumers proposal for a Regulation. MEPs agreed on the need to focus on key issues for their upcoming vote. Several MEPs mentioned: Next step: —— On 21 February 2011, the Council adopted its position on the Food Information to Consumers proposal for a Regulation. The Council position is available here. On 22 February 2011, the European Commission published a Communication concerning the Council position at first reading on the adoption of the Regulation on food information to consumers. You will find here the Commission views on the Council position. Next step: —— On 7 December 2010, the Employment, Social Policy, Health and Consumer Affairs Council met in order to give its opinion on the proposed Regulation. Member States reached political agreement, at first reading, on the following elements: – A mandatory nutrition declaration including the labelling of the energy value and the quantities of the following nutrients: fat, saturates, carbohydrates, protein, sugars and salt, Next step: The political agreement will be formally adopted during the February Council session. The text will then go back to the European Parliament for its second reading. —– In a highly disappointing move, the June plenary session of the European Parliament voted against including traffic lights in food labelling legislation. At the same time, Members of Parliament voted to include nutrient profiles and this step has been hailed by the public health community. EPHA press release on the vote can be found here. —– In view of the vote on the Food Information to Consumers Regulation which will take place on 16 June 2010, EPHA has sent the following voting recommendations to the members of the European Parliament. 1. Front-of-pack labelling: support a mandatory front-of-pack labelling for energy, saturated fats, sugar and salt SUPPORT: 144, 287 EPHA recommends that energy, saturated fats, sugar and salt be included on the front-of-pack label to guarantee a public health approach to labelling. It is particularly important that these nutrients be highlighted as a reduction in their intake will significantly reduce the risk of cardiovascular disease and obesity. 2. Colour coding / traffic lights scheme: Support ‘traffic lights’ to appear on the front of pack SUPPORT: 288, 313, 314, 315 A Colour coding / traffic light system makes clear to people whether a product contains low, medium or high levels of a certain nutrient and helps them to make choices both within and across food categories. In addition, this had already been implemented by several retailers in the UK, Spain and Portugal on their own brand products The traffic light system would be particularly useful on convenience foods (i.e.: food which has been commercially prepared to be quickly and easily eaten, as this is where people have the most difficulty identifying healthier options. 3. Back-of-pack labelling: Support a mandatory back-of-pack nutrition declaration for the “big eight” (energy, protein, carbohydrates, sugars, fibre, fat, saturated fats and salt) plus trans fats. SUPPORT: 287, 313*Update 6 July 2011*
– regarding the labelling of alcoholic beverages and transfats, both issues have been exempted from the current legislation. However, the Commission should “reconsider”, by the end of 2014, whether to include alcoholic beverages in the legislation and amend the current text. By the same time, the European Commission should also conduct an evaluation of the risks/advantages of the presence of transfats in the foodstuff and take the necessary measures (possibly to restrict their use as it is already the case in several countries, Denmark notably).
– the possibility to use additional forms of expression.*Update 22 June 2011*
1) the energy value and the amounts of fat, saturates, carbohydrates, protein, sugars and salt should be indicated in the same field of vision per 100gr/100ml and in addition per portion, they can also be presented using the GDA (Guideline Daily Amounts) scheme per 100gr/100ml or per portion or both,
2) the energy value should ALWAYS be indicated per 100gr/100ml (and in addition per portion if wanted). When the four nutrients are repeated together with the energy labelling, they should be labelled per portion only. In that case, the energy value must be expressed per portion and per 100gr/100ml.
———-*Update 16 March 2011*
– the five key nutrients to appear on the Front of the Pack,
– transfats to be mandatorily labelled
– country of origin to be labelled.
Amongst other issues, alcopops labelling as well as labelling per 100gr/ml were also mentioned.
– ENVI Committee vote: 19 April 2011
– Plenary vote: July 2011.*Update 21 February 2011*
– ENVI discussion: 16 March 2011,
– Deadline for amendments: 18 March 2011,
– ENVI Committee vote foreseen for 12 April 2011,
– Plenary vote foreseen for 5 July 2011.*Update 7 December 2010*
– The energy value and the amounts of these nutrients to be expressed per 100g or per 100ml, but could also be indicated as a percentage of reference intakes.
– The possible use of additional forms of expression or presentation as long as certain conditions are met (e.g. they do not mislead consumers and are supported by evidence of understanding of such forms of expression or presentation by the average consumer),
– All elements of the nutrition declaration to appear together in the same field of vision but some elements may be repeated on the “front of pack”.
– To exempt certain alcoholic beverages (such as wines, products derived from aromatized wines, mead, beer, spirits, but not alcopops) from nutrition labelling rules as well as from the indication of the list of ingredients. The Commission should, however, examine within five years after the entry into force of the new regulation if this exemption is still justified.
– Non-prepacked food would also be exempted from nutrition labelling, unless Member States decide otherwise.
– A minimum font size for the mandatory information on the labelling which, added to other criteria, such as contrast, is aimed to ensure the legibility of the labels.*Update* 16 June 2010
*Update* 14 June 2010
Front-of-pack nutrition information is not comprehensive and only serves as guidance for people. A full nutrition declaration on the back of pack should therefore provide them with information covering the ‘big eight’ (energy, protein, carbohydrates, sugars, fibre, fat, saturated fats and salt) plus trans fats.
4. Per 100g/100ml labelling: Vote for a mandatory labelling per 100g/100ml with the possibility to additionally refer to per portion.
SUPPORT: 32, 150
REJECT: 297
Portion sizes vary from one person to another and from one product to another: It would be difficult to provide people with standardised information if using portion size. It therefore makes sense to give information per 100g or per 100 ml, making labels comparable for them.
5. Reference Values: support amendments to review them in the light of international recommendations and EFSA’s opinion
SUPPORT: 31
The values currently foreseen in Annex XI of the Regulation differ from international recommendations. Taking into account the opinion from the European Food Safety Authority on Dietary Reference Values and science-based nutrient intake recommendations for the general population that have been established by International authorities, the labeling reference intakes for total fat, saturated fat, carbohydrate, sugars and salt should be re-examined by the Commission.
6. Legibility: support a minimum font size and mandatory elements
SUPPORT: 67, 311
EPHA considers that a minimum font size of 1.2mm height and detailed mandatory elements shall be taken into account for ensuring legibility and readability for everyone.
7. Nutrient Profiles: Reject deleting nutrient profiles
REJECT: 191
Nutrient profiles are meant to ensure that products that bear heath or nutrition claims are overall healthy. They are a tool for responsible marketing. They aim to avoid a situation where the overall nutritional status of a product is unhealthy. For example, while low in sugar, a product could actually be high in fat and therefore should not bear a nutrition or health claim: this would mislead people when they are trying to make healthier choices.
In this context, the Health and Nutrition Claims Regulation will not be able to fulfill its full purpose without nutrient profiles. EPHA strongly recommends and supports the reinstatement of nutrient profiles as a tool to ensure that claims are genuine.
Additionally, the Corporate Europe Observatory has recently published a report on the money invested by the food industry to block the adoption of an EU-wide traffic lights labelling scheme. More information can be found here.
——-
*Update* 22 March 2010
On 16 March 2010, the European Parliament Committee on Environment, Public health and Food Safety voted to adopt the Renate Sommer’s report. Public health arguments were not prioritised in the vote, although they were not entirely ignored.
The Committee voted to delete the article establishing nutrient profiles from the Nutrition and Health Claims Regulation and the amendments in favour of mandatory colour coding on the front of pack (traffic light scheme) were not adopted. However, the tight vote on the traffic light scheme (30 – 30) shows that there is still time for MEPs to reframe the debate and prioritise health needs.
In addition, progress should be noted such as the full nutrition declaration to appear on the back of pack, a mandatory front of pack for select nutrients and the mandatory declaration of transfats.
EPHA calls on the European Parliament to fulfill its responsibility to protect public health in Europe and will continue to cooperate with MEPs in the run up to the plenary vote that will take place in May 2010.
On 23 February 2010, the European Parliament Committee on the Internal Market and Consumer Affairs voted to adopt the Draft Opinion by Christel Schaldemose MEP (S&D, DK). EPHA had previously submitted its voting recommendations to the Committee members. The position of the rapporteur in IMCO was not in line with EPHA’s position, with only the Greens/EFA shadow supporting our position. On the day of the vote, not a single amendment was made to improve the text in terms of public health goals. The draft opinion was adopted by 21 votes to 15, with 3 abstentions.
The draftsperson explained that the vote had resulted in the deletion of chapters 6 and 7, voluntary and national schemes, and consequently the S&D group could not vote in favour of the draft opinion, despite other amendments constituting an improvement to the proposal. This is a strong indication of the strength of the EPP group in the European Parliament.
——
*Update* 29 January 2009
Renate Sommer MEP (EPP, Germany) presented her report to ENVI Committee, on 30 November 2009. Christel Schaldemose MEP (S&D, Denmark), presented her report to the IMCO Committee on 1 December 2009. The shadow rapporteurs in both committees were given the opportunity to comment.
Following the presentation of the reports, MEPs submitted amendments to the original Commission proposal.
On 25 January 2010, the IMCO Committee met for the consideration of the amendments. In total 281 amendments were considered by the MEPs. The Greens/EFA group tabled amendments in line with EPHA’s position, whilst certain members of the S&D Group are also in line. The Rapporteur in IMCO shares some elements with EPHA, but does not propose the traffic light and does not stipulate front of pack. The EPP and ECR groups are opposed. The vote in IMCO will take place on 23 February 2010. Christel Schaldemose MEP will convene a meeting for the rapporteurs on 2 February 2010.
On 27 January 2010, the ENVI Committee met to follow the consideration of amendments. The ENVI Committee is the lead committee on this dossier. The rapporteurs for the Greens/EFA group, the S&D group and the GUE/NL are all in favour of traffic lights. The EPP, ALDE and ECR rapporteurs oppose. The vote will take place on 16 March 2010
The vote will take place on 16 March.
—–
*Update* 23 October 2009
In Strasbourg, EPHA met with the Rapporteur in IMCO Christel Schaldemose, and shadow rapporteurs Glennis Willmott (ENVI), Kartika Liotard (ENVI), Struan Stevenson (ENVI) and Emma McClarkin (IMCO).
The report in ENVI has been pushed back to 11 November 2009, and is now the same date as in IMCO. The deadline for amendments will be 7 December 2009.
—–
*Update* 1 October 2009
The European Parliament will revisit the proposal. The Environment, Public Health and Food Safety (ENVI) Committee is the lead committee and IMCO (Internal Market and Consumer Protection) and AGRI (Agriculture) will both give opinions.
In the ENVI Committee the rapporteurs are as follows:
Rapporteur- Renate Sommer (EPP-DE)
Shadow Rapporteurs- Wilmott (S&D-UK), Liotard (GUE- NL), Gerbrandij (ALDE- NL), Stevenson (ECR- UK), Schylter (Greens- SE)
In the IMCO Committee the rapporteurs are as follows:
Rapporteur- Schaldemose (S&D-DK)
Shadow Rapporteurs- Emma McClarkin (ECR-UK)
In the AGRI Committee the rapporteur is as follows:
Tarabella (S&D- DE).
Renate Sommer is due to submit her report to the ENVI Committee by mid-October and ammendments to the draft report must be submitted by 17 November 2009.
Background
EU legislation on food labelling has three main aims:
– to inform and protect citizens;
– to enhance the free movement of food products;
– to enable consumers to make informed choices.
The principle used to develop EU laws is that of functional labelling. This means making sure that consumers can get all the information that they need on the ingredients of the product, the manufacturer and the way that the product should be be stored and prepared. Once these legal obligations have been met, the food industry is free to provide any additional information that they choose on the condition that it is is accurate and does not mislead the consumer.
The challenge for European legislators is to ensure that the diverse needs and interests of consumers can be met. For example, a vegetarian, a person with a shellfish allergy, someone suffering from high blood pressure and a dieter all want to know different things about a particular food item. The food label has to deliver the relevant information and still be feasible for food producers, both large and small. Issues to be addressed include listing of ingredients, methods of production and process, allergens, nutrition composition, health and nutrition claims, origin of the product, safe use and preparation, GM derivatives, non pre-packed food, use of symbols and the presentation of subsidiary and mandatory information.
In the proposal for a Regulation (COM (2008) 40 final – 2008/0028 (COD)) mandatory nutrition declarations are proposed for the first time in EU legislation. Clear and easily-understood nutrition labelling is a crucial element in a strategy to address the massive nutrition-related health problems in Europe such as cardiovascular diseases and obesity.
Issues
EPHA welcomes the proposal from the Commission but believes that even more steps should be taken to protect the health and wellbeing
of European citizens in combating the fight against obesity.
One of the most important tools to prevent obesity is to be enable consumers to identify healthy food choices. In the proposal on ‘Food information to consumers’ (page 4), the Commission states that one of the conclusions resulting from the initial consultation is that ‘consumers demand more and better information on labels and are interested in clear, simple, comprehensive and standardised and authoritative information’. This is a direct message from the consumers to indicate that current labelling is simply not good enough.
Another conclusion from the proposal of the Commission is that
‘consumers find it difficult to read and understand labels’ and EPHA therefore proposes the introduction of a mandatory traffic light
labelling scheme on the Front of Pack (FoP) to empower the consumers.
EPHA would like to stress the importance of producing European Dietary Nutrition Guidelines to support the proposal on Regulation. A harmonization of the existing national guidelines is necessary to provide a reference point to compare diet against for consumers to develop harmonized guidance. This work could be carried out by European Food Safety Authority (EFSA).
The obesity epidemic has a tremendous effect on social and economic development in Europe and EPHA believes that efficient and understandable labelling is a part of a first step to tackle the problem and enhance better food information to consumers. For more details on our position please click here
For more information
EPHA related articles
– [->art2959]
